Cincinnati CityBeat is your free source for Cincinnati and Ohio news, arts and culture coverage, restaurant reviews, music, things to do, photos, and more.
At first glance, Main Street Tavern is easy to overlook among the other trendy spots on the road with updated exteriors. The Tavern is in the building that once held Mulligans Pub and still rocks some of the gritty bar vibes, with chipped paint and a few beer signs. In fact, the building housed the original Main Street Tavern before it was Mulligans, which was around for 73 years, arguably making this Main Street Tavern an automatic mainstay on the strip.
In a twist that epitomizes the passion that has gone into making this restaurant a reality, co-owner Bill Lynch (with Trent Riley) is also the chef and menu creator. Our server didnt hesitate to tell us how much Lynch loves food, and happily declared that the only store-bought items Lynch allows on the premises are ketchup, mustard and mayonnaise. After tasting the food, I can well believe it.
The restaurant has an excellent dinner menu, but in a smart move, it also serves brunch from 10 a.m.-3 p.m. on Saturdays and Sundays with various delicious looking arrangements of waffles, biscuits, gravy, meats, French toast and sandwiches. A few other weekly specialty events include Service Industry Mondays, Fancy Grilled Cheese Tuesdays (here for it; this night also includes $3 cherry and grape bombs), Waffle Wednesdays and $3 Craft Can Thursdays.
The exterior of Main Street Tavern, formerly Mulligan’s Pub Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowA spread of brunch dishes available at Main Street Tavern Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe dining room and jukebox Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowA spread of dishes available at Main Street Tavern Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowBiscuits and gravy with fried chicken Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe Cowboy Bill Watts Burger ($12), made with local beef and topped with pimento cheese, crispy fried onions, barbecue sauce, lettuce and tomato. Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowHomemade cheesecake ($5) with a biscuit crust and cranberry compote. Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe biscuit and baloney sliders ($7), with either sweet or spicy sauce and a hefty scoop of chow-chow (a sort of pickled vegetable relish). Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe bar Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe Revs Fried Chicken ($14), with fried bird offset by a rich peppered milk gravy that comes draped on top of a leg, thigh and boneless breast. Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe dining room Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe Elvis French toast with bacon, peanut butter and banana Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowMain Street Tavern sign Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe burger, fried chicken, sliders and cheesecake Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe dining room Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowThe dining room Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowCowboy Bill Watts Burger Hailey Bollinger and Paige DeglowMore cheesecake angles Hailey Bollinger and Paige Deglow