Hamilton County Administration Building Photo: Nick Swartsell

Hamilton County Administration Building Photo: Nick Swartsell

All three members of the Hamilton County Commission today voted to implement a .25 percent sales tax in April next year to bridge a $20 million budget gap.

That tax, however, will not lead to an overall increase in the county’s 7 percent sales tax rate because it will replace the expiring tax levy approved to pay for the restoration of Union Terminal. Voters passed the so-called “icon tax” in 2014 to raise $200 million for the restoration of the terminal and it is set to expire in April next year.

Hamilton County Administrator Jeff Aluotto says extending the tax would raise $60 million through 2021, sufficient to close the upcoming funding gap.

“We’ve been treading water here for a while in Hamilton County,” Hamilton County Commission President Denise Driehaus said at today’s commission meeting. “From my point of view, it’s time to sink or swim — and we’re going to swim. We’ve closed buildings, we’ve reduced staff. We’re on furloughs and hiring freezes. We’ve had additional challenges in recent years with cuts to the state’s funding. And we’ve had an increase in need related to the opioid epidemic.”

The county has struggled with increasing costs, a sales-tax-revenue-sapping deal for Cincinnati’s two riverfront stadiums as well as dwindling revenues from the state’s local government fund. Hamilton County lost $66 million in state funding between 2011 and 2017, Hamilton County Auditor Dusty Rhodes has said.

“Hamilton County has become the biggest donor county in all of Ohio to the operations of state government,” commission member Todd Portune said.

A big part of the problem, according to commissioners: the small portion of the sales tax going to the county’s operating fund. And 75 percent of that money goes to public safety — county courts, the sheriff’s office and the justice center. 

The county’s local sales tax is 1.25 percent, but only .5 goes to the county’s operating budget due to the two stadium deals and other issues. Meanwhile, Cuyahoga County’s sales tax rate is 2.25 percent, and 1.2 percent of that goes to the county’s operating fund. Franklin County’s local sales tax is also 1.25 percent, and it dedicates it all to its operating fund. Just to the north, Warren County dedicates all of its 1.25 percent to operations as well.

“Here we sit today well under where everyone else is, and we’re just not getting the same partnership dollars from the state,” Driehaus said.

Commissioners say property taxes are already too high and not a good source for new revenue. Hamilton County Recorder Norbert Nadel, a Republican who supports the sales tax boost, agreed.

“Everybody pays it — as opposed to the usual practice of soaking property owners with excessive tax increases,” he said. 

But the extension of the sales tax will likely face derision from conservative groups.

A move last year to boost the county’s sales tax by .2 percent met with strong resistance from conservatives, who mounted a petition drive to repeal the hike. County commissioners rescinded the proposed increase. 

Tax opponents would need roughly 34,000 signatures to get a tax repeal referendum on the ballot this time around. 

Portune, Driehaus and fellow commission member Stephanie Summerow-Dumas, all Democrats, pointed to a study conducted by the Cincinnati Business Committee and Cincinnati Regional Business Committee that took a deep dive into the county’s finances. That study, they say, showed that the county needed to increase revenue as well as find ways to become more efficient in certain areas, including its aging IT systems.

“What it says is that there is a need for increased revenue and increased efficiencies,” Driehaus said. “When you look at other counties and what they’ve done in recent years, they’ve increased their sales tax.”

Leave a comment