I turned up at Broadway’s St. James Theatre on Nov. 12 for Something Rotten with moderate expectations. I had seen a number from the show on the Tony Awards last June, so I knew it was an amusing backstage mash-up of Elizabethan England and musical theater. It sounded like fun, but I wasn’t completely prepared for just how polished the ensemble would be, delivering a ton of energy and laughs from start to finish — starting with the opening number, “Welcome to the Renaissance,” led by Michael James Scott as an expressive minstrel. The song is a descriptive, cartoonish set-up for the rough-and-tumble world of 16th-century London.
We quickly meet Nick Bottom (Brian d’Arcy James), a disgruntled playwright who lives in the shadow of Shakespeare and chafes at the very mention of his adversary’s name: “I Hate Shakespeare” is a song by the writing team of Wayne and Karey Kirkpatrick that will surely have a life of its own in years to come. Nick’s younger brother Nigel (John Cariani) is the real poet in the crowd, but he’s not very assertive and no one pays him any heed — despite the fine words he’s capable of crafting.
As Nigel’s wife Bea, Heidi Bickenstaff (with a powerful voice that stood out in every number she performs), has lots of opportunities to play with the roles of women in England four centuries ago. She poses as a man to get join the all-male acting company, and she gives new meaning to the famous line “to Be(a) or not to Be(a).”
But several supporting roles truly ramp up the humorous voltage of Something Rotten, most particularly Christian Borle as the Bard himself. He’s a preening superstar with a Rock-star presence when he sings “Will Power,” and we see that he’s a conniving cheat in numbers like “Hard to Be the Bard” and “To Thine Own Self.”
Further digging for laugh-inducing gold are Gerry Vichi as Shylock (the moneylender from Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice is now an investor who backs shows) and Brad Oscar as Nostradamus, the shortsighted seer who sets Nick down a misguided path to produce Omelette: The Musical — rather than Hamlet.
The explication of what “A Musical” is and the phenomenon it will become in the future was the musical number that entertained the Tony Award audience in June. It’s a good sample of the inside-joke nature of this show — if you’re a theater fan, you’ll get lots of the humor. If not, well, there’s a ton of snappy tap-dancing, an immense wardrobe of crazy costumes and enough pratfalls and silliness to keep you entertained for two-and-a-half hours.
In truth, Something Rotten isn’t rotten at all, although its humor could get stale with too many repetitions. However, it is the kind of show that will do well when it tours to cities across America. You can rest assured that it will show up at Cincinnati’s Aronoff Center sooner or later.
SOMETHING ROTTEN is now onstage at St. James Theatre in New York. More info: RottenBroadway.com.
This article appears in Dec 2-8, 2015.


