Were Claude Monet to look at the black-and-white photographs that William Messer took of Giverny over a 20-year period — photographs featured in the Over Time exhibit at The Carnegie through Feb. 7 — he would say, “You missed the point!”
The point, so clearly illustrated through Monet’s many paintings of the water lilies in the pond at his Giverny gardens in France, was the color of the flowers and the way its relationship to light alters how we view.
Indeed, that is why millions of people have gone to visit Giverny since Fondation Claude Monet restored its two gardens and house. (The property was opened to the public in 1980.) They want to try to see Giverny the way they think Monet did while there from 1883 to his death in 1926.
But not so fast. Monet’s point, ultimately, was to make art by seeing the familiar in a new and different way. Messer’s motivation is the same. Not to say that what he has done is equal in accomplishment to Monet’s breakthroughs, but it’s an interesting project that rewards those who spend time with it. Messer curates the photo shows at Iris BookCafe, and his eye for composition extends to his own work.
Over Time is nicely installed at The Carnegie. Messer is one of three area artists who share the exhibit, which is about projects that over the course of years return to specific imagery, locations or materials.
The other artists are John Lanzador, who makes bas relief wood carvings featuring the small plastic figurine of a female bowler, and David Parks, who photographed changes in Denver’s urban core during the 1970s and 1980s.
Each gets a well-lit room to display his work. Messer’s contains 40 photographs, all modestly sized prints, some in vertical format and some horizontal. The layout looks sleek and enticing, if not immediately dramatically striking.
As a writer, Messer has a nice, slightly Proustian touch — his artist statement is remembrance of a project past that combines romanticism, melancholia and vivid descriptive detail.
He starts by recalling a “not-yet-divorced wife of a powerful American lawyer” he met in the south of France, and with whom he took walks, meals and nude photographs as they “celebrated her momentary relative freedom.”
At some point in the early 1980s, the woman invited him to come with her and her daughter to Giverny. As he recounts, he wasn’t interested in photographing flower gardens. But he did ultimately take a few photographs — black-and-white and from a portrait distance, so as not to have either close-ups or landscapes. He wanted to avoid succumbing to expectations.
And then he waited months to develop. He liked what he saw, and that began a yearly journey, until 2005, to discover Giverny his way. The administrators cooperated, making the place available to him at hours when it was otherwise closed.
Looking at the exhibit, I at first didn’t see what Messer describes seeing and capturing in his statement. Like everyone else, I’m used to a grabber that immediately draws my attention at an exhibit like this, maybe something Impressionist-inspired. But over time in the gallery, I began to notice what Messer also slowly saw during his 20-year project.
Even without color, this is a beautiful place. The shapes, forms and abundance of the flowers, the textures of nature, the leaves, a wheelbarrow, the Japanese bridge … everything fits into something larger without dominating. It’s all very egalitarian.
And really, there is color — in the mind’s eye. The clear skies seem to be radiant; the play of shadows on the lily pads is coolly mysterious, and small white flowers leap forward. The most memorable photograph isn’t even of a flower — it’s of a tree branch, either just budding or with raindrops, jutting out from the softer-focus background. This is how seasons change.
It wasn’t until I read Messer’s statement that I realized a certain willow tree eventually got ill and was cut, thus no longer a part of the photographs.
“Its absence seemed to have changed the garden completely,” Messer wrote. “But perhaps it was I who had changed more. I knew the project was done.”
I’m reminded of the old question about, “If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound.” In these photos, you see not just what’s there but also what’s gone. You can’t hear it, but you can sure miss it.
For more information, visit thecarnegie.com.
CONTACT Steven Rosen: srosen@citybeat.com
This article appears in Jan 28 – Feb 3, 2015.


