Cincinnati CityBeat is your free source for Cincinnati and Ohio news, arts and culture coverage, restaurant reviews, music, things to do, photos, and more.
Sometimes a sort of unreasonable hunger strikes, and when that time comes, a regular ol’ grilled cheese just won’t cut it. Lucky for you, the Queen City is well-equipped with a multitude of over-the-top dishes to feast upon, ranging from a breadstick the size of your arm to a s’more made with donuts, to an eight-pound 6-way (yes, you read that correctly). Here are a few places to head when you’ve got an extreme case of the munchies.
Guti Nachos with pollo asado: corn chips topped with refried beans, guacamole, mozzarella, cilantro, onion and cotija cheese, served with sour cream, roja and verde salsas Photo: Mary LeBusMac’s Pizza Pub
Multiple locations including 205 W. McMillan, CUF
Mac’s Pizza Pub is a college staple and caters to those who may have had a few brews (or aren’t old enough to worry about their waistline yet). One particularly over-the-top menu item is the restaurant’s Chicago Gyro Pizza, made with a garlic butter base and topped with spinach, olives, tomatoes and onions, gyro meat, mozzarella, provolone and feta and finished with tzatziki sauce. Pair it with fried pickles and you have the perfect munchie fest. Photo: facebook.com/macspizzapubcliftonNo Freakin’ Way Challenge
Blue Ash Chili (9565 Kenwood Road, Blue Ash, 513-984-6107; 4200 Aero Drive, Mason, 513-492-9650; 11711 Princeton Pike, Tri-County, 513-873-4663
The Feat: Conquer an 8-pound plate of Cincinnati-style chili ($39.99)
The Time Frame: 60 minutes
Two and a half pounds of spaghetti. Two and a half pounds of premium chili. Two pounds of shredded cheddar cheese. A pound of jalapeño caps. That’s a lot of chili, and you’ll need to clean your plate to conquer Blue Ash Chili’s No Freakin’ Way challenge. The restaurant is known just as much for its eclecticism — the flagship Blue Ash store channels an old-fashioned diner with classic records lining the walls — as it is for its Cincinnati-style chili served 3, 4, 5 or 6 ways; the latter was even featured on Guy Fieri’s Diners, Drive-ins & Dives in 2010. But if six ways (a standard serving of spaghetti, chili, cheese, onions, beans and sliced jalapeños or fried bottle caps) just doesn’t cut it, the No Freakin’ Way Challenge takes things to the next, larger level. Eighty-three people have attempted the challenge — including Josh Denny of the Food Network’s Ginormous Food — but only five have won. Not even Denny was victorious.
Photo: Hailey Bollinger Photo: Hailey BollingerGomez Salsa
Multiple locations, including 2437 Gilbert Ave., Walnut Hills
Gomez’s has it all: fish tacos with Baja sauce, chips with pineapple salsa, taco salad bowls and owner Andrew Gomez’s greatest invention — the Turtle Shell. Take a tortilla, stuff it with rice, beans, sour cream, lettuce, salsa, meat, veggies and cheese, layer in a tostado for crunch, put some cheese on the top and then brown it. It’s a fat little crunchy burrito envelope — a true walking taco. Photo: Lindsay McCartyThe Root Beer Stand
11566 Reading Road, Sharonville
Opened as an A&W Root Beer Stand in 1957, the now family-owned restaurant makes secret-recipe root beer (available by the jug) using water from the property’s 280-foot-deep well and secret-recipe chili for their famous foot-long coney dogs. At the top of our list is the Timmy Dog, a footlong dog loaded with chili, cheese, onions, mustard, hot sauce, ketchup, relish, slaw and sauerkraut. Photo: Sami Stewart | The Root Beer StandPig Candy BBQ
5901 Kellogg Ave., California, Ohio
Pig Candy BBQ opened several years ago in an old jail in the Cincinnati neighborhood California, and its namesake comes from its signature menu item: The Pig Candy waffle. The waffle is pressed with pulled pork and drizzled with a peach maple glaze. Other offerings, like the pulled pork or sliced brisket sandwich, are sure to satisfy your barbecue cravings. Photo: facebook.com/eatpigcandyFifty West Burger Bar
7605 Wooster Pike, Columbia Township
An homage to a 1950s roadside root beer stand, Fifty West Burger Bar serves a handful of proteins — single or double burger, chicken patty, flattop dog or Beyond burger — 12 different ways, each named for the 12 different states U.S. Route 50 travels through. Ohio’s burger tops our cravings list with Cincinnati chili, shredded cheese, house mustard and onions. Photo: Savana WillhoiteFireside Pizza
773 E. McMillan St., Walnut Hills
Pizza is a classic munchie food, and Fireside Pizza in Walnut Hills does it well. Fireside partners with Eli’s BBQ for the aptly named Eli’s BBQ Pie that comes piled high with Alabama white sauce, a provolone-mozzarella mix, Eli’s BBQ signature rub and barbecue sauce, pickled red onions and Fireside’s oven-roasted chicken. Pizzas are available in both 9 inches and 14 inches, but we think you’ll want the bigger size. Thank us later. Photo: Provided by FiresideSugar
6 W.14th St., Over-the-Rhine
Sugar has specialty deluxe and classic cookies available, with nearly 30 flavors to choose from. If you’re in the mood for something big and sweet, try their chocolate chip cookie bomb, a chocolate chip cookie coated with extra chocolate chips and weighing in at half a pound — before toppings. Need we say more? Photo:Trotta’s Pizza & Drive Thru
3501 Werk Road, Westwood
This family-owned pizzeria is known for ample toppings and a crust you can’t pass up. A unique menu item is their Trotta’s Big Boy specialty pizza that comes with tartar sauce, lettuce, pickles, ground beef and cheddar cheese. Since you’re in Cincinnati, you might as well get goetta on top too. Photo: Devin LuginbillBandito Park + Cantina
3543 Columbia Parkway, Columbia Tusculum
Bandito Food Park is a one-of-a-kind restaurant and event venue with an outer park-like atmosphere with fun food and beverages to match. If you wind up at Bandito with the munchies, they have some very 4/20-friendly snacking — from birria-stuffed mac and cheese and stacked nachos to the Dude Seriously taco. It comes with seasoned ground beef, shredded cheese, crushed Takis chips and housemade sauce. Photo: Hailey BollingerChandler’s Burger Bistro
6135 Cleves Warsaw Pike, Delhi; 10533 Harrison Ave., Harrison
Chandler’s has a variety of unique burgers and sandwiches, none more mouth-watering than the Nati Melt, which is a burger with bacon squeezed between two grilled cheese sandwiches (you’ve got that right — the grilled cheese sandwiches are the bun. Photo: facebook.com/chandlersburgerbistroKeystone Mac Shack
2612 Short Vine, Corryville
Keystone Mac Shack is known for deliciously gooey mac and cheese. Any of Keystone’s mac and cheese options would be a delightful craving cure, but we are keen on the B.B. King mac and cheese with barbecue chicken and bacon, topped with melted cheddar cheese and drizzled with barbecue sauce. Photo: facebook.com/KeystoneCliftonGordo’s Pub & Grill
4328 Montgomery Road, Norwood
The menu at Gordo’s Pub & Grill excels at unique and over-the-top burger creations. Try the BPJ, which stands for banana, peanut butter and jam. Plus bacon. We can’t forget about that. The banana is fried, the peanut butter has been whipped into a chunky cream cheese and the bacon is smoked. (Not pictured). Photo: Hailey BollingerGoodfellas Pizzeria
1211 Main St., Over-the-Rhine; 6099 Montgomery Road, Pleasant Ridge; 603 Main St., Covington
Goodfellas Pizzeria features New York-style pizza in a 1920s-inspired setting. The wait in line to try their popular pizza can be long, especially on the weekends, but it’s worth it. Alongside their giant slices and pies, a standout menu item is their $4 breadstick that is literally the size of your arm and comes covered in garlic butter, parmesan and oregano. Photo: facebook.com/GoodfellasMainstrasseAgave & Rye
Multiple locations
Diners flock to Agave & Rye to enjoy its vibrant murals and funky decor while chowing down on unique tacos, with proteins including kangaroo, duck, crab cakes, lobster, crispy cauliflower, fries and crispy chicken — in addition to more familiar bases like steak, pork carnitas and mahi mahi. Try the Crown Jewel, a double-shelled taco with butter-poached lobster, shiitake mushrooms, mac and cheese, truffle oil and shaved green onions if you’re in the mood for a unique flavor combination. Photo: Hailey BollingerTom & Chee
Multiple locations including 125 E. Court St., Downtown
Tom & Chee is a well-loved grilled cheese staple, but one of its most indulgent items from the chain is on its dessert menu. Their S’more Donut is a classic glazed donut that has been grilled and stuffed with graham crackers, marshmallow mascarpone and chocolate, like a campfire on-the-go. Photo: facebook.com/tomandcheenewport/Eishaus (Temporarily Closed)
117 Park Place, Covington
Eishaus is home to spaghetti eis, a German ice cream dish that has the appearance of spaghetti. Spaghetti eis can be topped with different fruits and chocolate to form a visually striking and delicious dessert. The Spaghetti ‘3-Way’, a play on Cincinnati style chili, includes eis (vanilla ice cream), chocolate sauce with rice crispies, yellow chocolate shavings and mini vanilla wafers. If you’re under the influence it might look a little too much like a meal from Skyline. Photo: facebook.com/Eishauscov