A Covington Italian restaurant is in the running to be named the “Best New Restaurant” in the United States, and they need your help to win.
Carmelo’s was nominated alongside 19 other restaurants across the country in USA Today’s 10Best New Restaurants Reader’s Choice Award poll. Nominees were selected by a panel of food and travel experts based on excellence in menu execution, overall dining experience and hospitality.
Now, it’s up to voters to decide if Carmelo’s will earn the top spot. Supporters can vote here and can vote once every 12 hours. Voting ends on Monday, Dec. 22 at noon.
“Located in an 1850s office building in downtown Covington, Carmelo’s is an intimate and stylish dining venue focused on Italian American comfort cuisine. The menu features tried-and-true classics like eggplant parmigiana, mushroom marsala, and tiramisu,” writes USA Today.
Carmelo’s opened in October 2024 and is a collaboration between former Thunderdome Restaurant Group director of food and beverage Billy Grise and Chef Mitch Arens, who has helped create concepts like Beard & Bellies BBQ and Grub Local and is the founder and executive chef of Southernly, a local private chef company. Carmelo’s was named after Grise’s grandfather — an Italian American immigrant, family man and restaurant owner himself — and offers Italian American classics and handcrafted pasta dishes, like its 101-Layer Lasagna and Oxtail Ragu, in an inviting, rustic yet modern space.
“We’re incredibly honored,” Arens said in a press release. “This nomination reflects the community that believed in us from the moment we opened our doors. Everything we do, from the food to the service, comes from love.”
“Carmelo’s has always been about connection. People walk in as guests and leave as family. To be recognized alongside some of the best new restaurants in the country means the world to us,” added Grise.
Carmelo’s 434 Madison Ave., Covington. More info: eatatcarmelos.com.

