When Jared Bennett purchased the former Dutch’s space in Hyde Park, he transformed it into Hi-Dive, a neighborhood dive bar that looks like your grandma’s living room.

Bennett founded Hi-Dive to ensure the building remained a neighborhood gathering spot. However, he also runs his catering and take-out business, Jarrido’s, out of the old Dutch’s Larder area while providing food for the bar. It’s quite the contrast stepping back and forth between the cozy bar and the sleek industrial kitchen, which are so close to each other that people often wander into the kitchen thinking it’s a secret entry into the saloon.
“This whole space was part of Dutch’s before, but now it’s two separate businesses, which confuses a lot of people,” Bennett said. “We’ve got a sign out front that says ‘Hi-Dive is next door’ and people still wander in like ‘Hey, is this Hi-Dive?’ and I laugh and say ‘No, but you can walk through the patio door right there to get to it.'”

Right now, Jarrido’s is making all sorts of dishes for events all over the city, whether it’s something as simple as game-day specialties like wings and hanky pankys or something elaborate like wagyu steak tastings. Bennett — who’s worked in basically every culinary environment you can think of, from line cook to head chef of a fine-dining restaurant — is game for the challenge.
“Some people want us to pick everything, some people want to choose everything themselves. Some people will even tell us, ‘I saw this thing on TikTok two months ago, can you do it?'” he said.

They’ve got plenty of to-go options at Jarrido’s, too, provided you order in advance. Plenty of customers trying to hit their macros will order cooked proteins by the pound to pick up from the kitchen, for example. Other options include everything from blueberry pancakes to steak skewers to seared scallops.
As we finished our interview, I took a roasted carrot salad and a short rib lasagna (both great!) back to the office for lunch. The portions were so substantial that Bennett joked I’d “probably have to take a nap” after eating them both. He was correct.
In the future, as the business gets even more popular, Bennett plans to offer grab-and-go options that don’t require ordering ahead, so people can come in during the day and snag a home-cooked meal without preparing it themselves. Given the space’s history, though, he wants it to be a neighborhood hangout more than anything.

This Friday, he’s hosting a stand-up comedy night inside Jarrido’s to further reactivate the space as more than a kitchen, which he hopes will become a monthly event. Soon, he’ll begin hosting themed dinner nights for the community, too.
“We’re just trying to keep this place active… Dutch’s was a neighborhood staple, so we’re trying to honor that,” he said. “We’re just a neighborhood hangout. People come in and watch the game, hang out with the bartender, shoot the shit, so to speak. Seems like a lot of those places are starting to fade away, so it’s nice to have a spot to do so.”
For more information on Jarrido’s, visit the website. For more on Hi-Dive, visit the bar’s Instagram page.

