Once primarily the domain of health food stores, nut butters that aren’t peanut butter (or are variations on the peanut butter theme) have been popping up with greater frequency in average neighborhood supermarkets.
Peanut butter’s long-running popularity is understandable. (Chances are, if you check the cupboards in a majority of U.S. households, you’ll find a jar.) It’s fairly inexpensive and a decent source of protein. (I also use it to satisfy my sweet tooth in a pinch.)
The brands and variations of peanut butter are plentiful, with everything from natural and reduced-fat versions to honey-roasted and other flavors. Now, spreads made from other nuts are elbowing for some grocery store shelf space. And with the increasing stateside popularity of Nutella, that yummy chocolate/hazelnut spread that originated in Italy, more chocolate-laced nut butters are also joining the fray.
According to a recent report from the Specialty Food Association, nut and seed butters make up the fastest growing category of “specialty foods,” with sales up 51.6 percent over the past year. The website supermarketnews.com says the most popular nut butter (besides peanut) is almond, followed by hazelnut, soybean, cashew and sunflower. Bloomberg recently reported on the rise of nut butters’ popularity, asserting that the growth is coming as the price of other sources of protein (meat and dairy) soar to near record highs, even though nut butters aren’t particularly cheap.
I visited the peanut butter aisle at a local Kroger store and grabbed several of these new fangled nut butters for tasting. Jif brand nut butters are $6.99 for a 12-ounce jar; Kroger almond butter was only slightly cheaper at $6.69. While a few off-brands have shown otherwise, it’s kind of hard to screw up nut butter. My sampling of various products bore this out; though some were better than others, none of the nut butters I tried were “bad.”
Jif is all over the trend. The brand offers three hazelnut spreads (chocolate, salted caramel and mocha cappuccino), Whips (whipped peanut butter that comes in regular, chocolate and, of course, pumpkin pie spice) and almond and cashew butters — the only variations I could find on my shopping excursion. The Jif almond butter was smooth and subtle. The cashew butter was similar but had a richer cashew flavoring.
Jif has also gotten into the “single serving” peanut butter trend. Convenience stores often carry these smaller packages of peanut butter and Nutella. The Jif To Go offerings are packaged in boxes of eight or as Jif To Go Dippers, which contain a package of pretzels. These seem aimed at parents looking for a quick and easy lunchbox option, which no doubt thrills kids because there is a Chocolate Silk peanut butter version. While I expected it to resemble the taste of Nutella (it has the same dark-brown coloring), the Chocolate Silk flavor balance was a bit off. The peanut butter overwhelms the chocolate.
Hershey’s must’ve been watching the surge in Nutella’s popularity because the candy makers have their own line of chocolate nut spreads, substantially cheaper than the others at around $4 for a 13-ounce jar. The company offers chocolate with hazelnut, chocolate with almond and plain old chocolate. The jars’ packaging shows the spreads on a strawberry and a piece of bread, though the idea of putting this chocolate on a slice of Wonder bread seems gross; I tried the almond version and it’s pretty much cake icing.
Kroger’s in-house brands actually do a good job of mimicking some of these brand-name spreads. I found the Kroger brand of almond butter better than Jif’s version; the almond flavor is more pronounced and it tastes less sugary (though the nutritional information matches almost exactly). Kroger also fills a niche with its Crunchy Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa (the cheapest nut butter of the bunch at $2.69 for a 13-ounce jar).
For some reason and despite demand, Nutella hasn’t introduced a spread with chunks of hazelnuts. As the Kroger product proves, the crunchy concept works very well. Unlike crunchy peanut butter, where the oily peanuts blend in and seem more about texture than flavor, hazelnuts have more of a roasted quality that makes the flavor pop. And it actually audibly crunches when you chew. The Kroger spread is more watery, which makes it easier to dip fruit, something I always imagined would be very difficult to do with thick Nutella, despite it always being a serving suggestion. Nut butter options are plentiful and most are tasty, but you may want to check the nutritional labels first. Though not astronomical, the levels of fat are up there. Jif’s nut butters have between 16 and 18 grams of fat per serving; Nutella and the Hershey’s hazelnut spread, somewhat surprisingly, has less (12 grams).
This article appears in Oct 15-21, 2014.


