The convoluted path to a music venue at The Banks isn’t getting simpler any time soon. But the county and a company involved in a potential land swap that could make it happen say that deal isn’t dead in the water — or technically, at the water’s edge — yet.
That venue to be run by the Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra’s concert promotion arm MEMI is currently planned for a piece of land called Lot 27, which is just east of Paul Brown Stadium and subject to a veto by the Cincinnati Bengals thanks to its stadium lease with Hamilton County.
Cincinnati City Council hedged on approving a motion that would have expressed willingness to sell city-owned property to Hilltop Basic Resources, a building materials company currently on the banks of the Ohio River just west of Paul Brown Stadium, pending a deal that works for all parties. The Bengals and Hamilton County want to move Hilltop to create a so-called “green parking area” on their land where Bengals fans could tailgate. Currently, fans tailgate on Lot 27.
That motion would have created clarity for Hilltop that could allow a deal to develop, council member David Mann says. But his colleagues disagreed, saying the swap either isn’t necessary or isn’t fair.
The most attractive location for Hilltop, company leadership says, involves city-owned land in Queensgate. But some nearby businesses — including the headquarters of architectural design firm Elevar — and residents of nearby neighborhoods like East Price Hill and Sedamsville are protesting the proposed swap.
Residents, employees of another Queensgate company called Noramco that faces relocation if the swap happens and others have piled into City Hall this week to voice their opposition — and in some cases, their support — for the swap.
Greg Otis, senior vice president of strategic planning at Elevar, told council that the company wants to see environmental impact and traffic studies as well as the as-yet-announced location for a Hilltop asphalt plant before the land swap is approved.
Residents of East Price Hill warned about pollution that could happen in the neighborhoods due to proposed Hilltop asphalt and concrete plants.
“To be honest with you, I don’t understand why we’re having this obscene discussion about a music venue at all when there is another one being built across the river,” West Price Hill resident Laura Hamilton said. “We have far higher priorities in this city.”
Mayor John Cranley has long opposed the deal, preferring an alternate location for the music venue called Lot 24 that doesn’t require Hilltop’s relocation.
“I believe it is awful that we would take a heavy, dirty industry and dump it on the West Side,” Cranley said. “For what? Just so there could be tailgating 10 days a year at the riverfront?”
Pollution is a sensitive subject, especially in Lower Price Hill, the neighborhood that would be closest to a relocated Hilltop. That community has had to go through years of lead remediation for its soil and buildings, and in 2004, a fire at industrial site Queen City Barrel poured tons of dangerous toxins into the air.
However, some Lower Price Hill residents say they support the swap. They say Hilltop has been attentive to their concerns and has been convincing in pledges that it won’t pollute the area. Their main reason for support, however, is that Hilltop would turn over a parcel of land it has a purchase option on in the neighborhood that would be a key piece to a long-sought-after park called Price Landing.
Council member Greg Landsman says council’s refusal to pass the motion expressing willingness to sell the land gives a finality to the issue.
“In theory, I do think that for me that the idea of selling land is something I’m open to,” he said. “The problem is that it’s no longer theoretical. Voting yes would give false hope to those who want to see this current iteration of the plan move forward and unnecessary anger to those who want it stopped. So I think being done with it is good.”
Council did pass another motion promoted by Landsman asking the Bengals to stand down and let the music venue move forward without the land swap. That motion, however, has no force of law and is simply a suggestion.
Despite council’s refusal to say it would sell land to Hilltop, others say the land swap deal is not dead yet. Hilltop President and COO Kevin Sheehan says the company is still open to a deal for relocation, either with the city or the county, and has been looking into other locations, including some on the other side of the Ohio River. That would take Hilltop’s 70 employees and $150,000 in yearly payroll taxes outside Cincinnati.
“We’ll continue to listen,” he said after council’s meeting. “At this point, we’re supportive of the music venue. We’ll continue to talk with the county and the city as long as they continue to be interested in speaking with us about being part of the solution.”
Sheehan said some of the information council and others are asking for — namely, an environmental impact study — should be finalized shortly.
Meanwhile, the county seems locked on moving Hilltop somewhere. Hamilton County Commission member Todd Portune has said that he supports moving Hilltop elsewhere in Hamilton County. And Hamilton County’s attorney for issues related to The Banks, Tom Gabelman, says the county will work to provide more details in hopes of winning over council.
“I think additional information needs to be provided,” he said. “So there is a lot of work left to do… with Hilltop, all options are on the table for them. If it’s Queensgate, you have to provide more information to council. You heard David Mann say they need environmental, traffic, noise studies. I think that’s fair. I don’t have any problems with that.”
Gabelman says a plan needs to be in place by November so the venue can be open by fall next year.
Beyond the venue, though, he says the current situation provides “a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity” to get the land Hilltop occupies to turn it into a 15-acre, park-like setting that can double as parking during events. The county’s renegotiation of its contract with the Bengals could free up the money to do that, he said.
“It’s not the Bengals driving the Hilltop site,” he said. “We need that land for parking for The Banks. I’ve been trying to get Hilltop for 20 years, to be honest with you, because I know we need it to sustain The Banks.”
This article appears in Oct 2-15, 2019.


