Cincinnati’s city charter will not see a new amendment.
City voters rejected Issue 3, a series of anti-corruption measures, during the Nov. 2 general election. The amendment was designed to rein in the activities that caused many scandals among Cincinnati City Council members in recent years.
Instead of a single measure within an amendment, Issue 3 asked voters to approve a series of changes to the charter, which opponents predicted would be its downfall.
The issue had even more baggage. State Representative and city council candidate Tom Brinkman wrote the amendment and gathered signatures for it to appear on November’s ballot. But when the city printed the ballots, a word was changed from the initial language. Brinkman’s draft said “to establish the compensation for members of Council to the amount equal to the median household income for the City of Cincinnati and adjust that compensation annually,” while the city’s version changed “household” to “family,” changing the potential median salary.
City solicitor Andrew Garth claimed the change was a human error, while Brinkman wondered if it was done to sabotage the issue’s chances. The city declined reprinting the ballots with the original language. Some legal experts anticipate challenges.
Here was the full language that voters saw on the ballot Tuesday:
Shall the Charter of the City of Cincinnati be amended to require approval by Council before litigation on behalf of the City of Cincinnati or any of its officials can be filed; to establish the compensation for members of Council to the amount equal to the median family income for the City of Cincinnati and adjust that compensation annually; to require candidates for Mayor and Council to be residents of the City of Cincinnati for at least one year prior to assuming office; to eliminate the use of successor designation by members of the Council and to provide that if a member of council dies, resigns, or is removed, then the person who received the highest number of votes for election to council at the most recent municipal election but who was not declared elected to council at such election and who is not otherwise already serving or has served as a member of council since the most recent municipal election shall be the successor to hold the office for the remainder of the unexpired term of that member of council. To require the Mayor to assign legislative proposals to the appropriate committee no later than thirty days after being filed with the Clerk and to require the Mayor to put legislative proposals on the Council agenda no later than thirty days after they are reported out of Committee; to provide that the Mayor and members of Council are personally liable for violations of state law regarding open meetings or public records where the violation was to avoid or circumvent those laws or was purposeful, knowing, in bad faith, or in a wanton or reckless manner; and to provide for the removal of the Mayor as provided by state law and other processes, by amending existing Sections 3, 4, 4a, and 4b of Article II, “Legislative Power,” and amending Section 2 of Article III, “Mayor,” and enacting new Section 11 of Article IV, “Executive and Administrative Service,” and new Section 2c of Article IX, “Nominations and Elections.”
Cincinnati voters did, however, approve Issue 4, in which Kantam, L.L.C. (doing business as Andy’s BP) can now sell wine and mixed beverages between 10 a.m. and midnight on Sundays.
And Hamilton County voters approved two levies Tuesday. Issue 1 was a tax levy for children’s services that would continue support for the care and placement of children. For Issue 29, Great Parks of Hamilton County asked for a 10-year levy that would support infrastructure and improvements. Homeowners will now pay roughly $33.25 a year per $100,000 of home valuation annually, on top of the current levy of about $30 per $100,000; that levy expires in 2026.
Earlier Tuesday, Aftab Pureval defeated David Mann to become Cincinnati’s new mayor. In addition, three current Cincinnati City Council members kept their seats while six new members were voted in.
All results are preliminary until certified. See full election returns on the Hamilton County Board of Elections website.
Sign up for our weekly newsletters to get the latest on the news, things to do and places to eat delivered right to your inbox.
Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.
This article appears in Oct 27 – Nov 9, 2021.


