Since 1880, Cincinnati has been the only city in the United States to own its own railroad. Now, the city wants voters to transform the unique asset into a unique trust fund. Photo: Emory Davis

With a little over a week to go before the Nov. 7 election, and thousands of early votes already cast, city leaders are calling for big commitments from possible rail-sale dollars.

On Oct. 27, the office of Vice Mayor Jan-Michele Lemon Kearney issued a press release announcing two motions to be discussed in committee next week: one motion to repurpose the city’s Office of Human Relations into an “Office of Equity,” the other motion to “ensure equity in the disbursement of proceeds” from the potential sale of the Cincinnati Southern Railway (CSR) to Norfolk Southern.

The announcement comes one day after the second community “workshop” on Issue 22 hosted by the city, and one day after Black leaders assembled to convince voters that the sale would benefit “traditionally underserved areas.”

But Cincinnati NAACP President Joe Mallory told CityBeat that NAACP’s position is still “No” to Issue 22, saying the city’s efforts are too little too late.

Related

“They can call as many press conferences of supporters as they wish, they still can’t overcome their lack of transparency and community engagement,” said Mallory. “The first public facing event in Evanston on October 21 came 10 days after early voting had started.”

Council Member Scotty Johnson, a sponsor on the motions, said in the release he’s already voted “No” on Issue 22.

“I voted ‘No’ on the railroad sale because I wanted to see plans in place in writing to ensure equity for our Black communities – not just talk, but real commitment.” Johnson said. “And I’m not just talking about equity from the proceeds of the railway sale because state law limits those funds to modifying, repairing or replacing existing infrastructure.”

Motion to ensure equity from the CSR sale

In the motion on ensuring equity from rail-sale dollars,  Johnson, along with Council President Pro Tem Victoria Parks and Kearney, are proposing two funds for the 15 neighborhoods with the lowest income levels, known as the “Rising 15.”

Related

According to the news release, the first fund would directly come from the railway sale proceeds, the second fund would come from the general budget and go towards infrastructure projects for which the railway sale proceeds cannot be used, like new developments.

“The source of these funds for new projects is money in the capital budget that the city saves by using the railway sale proceeds for existing infrastructure projects,” the release reads.

Motion to create the Office of Equity

This motion states priority of this new office would be to close the racial wealth gap in Cincinnati. A seven-person community advisory committee would assist in identifying budgeting recommendations and tracking annual targets in the fiscal year.

Mayor Aftab Pureval is a sponsor on the motion to transform the Office of Human Relations into the Office of Equity, but not on the motion to ensure rail-sale dollars are allocated to Rising 15 neighborhoods.

“These motions will be discussed in committees next week,”Kearney wrote in an email announcing the motions. “The next step will be to have the law dept. to make these motions into ordinances. That takes a few months, so the idea is to get buy-in/commitment on the policies from City Council NOW.”

There will be one more city-sponsored information session to convince voters to approve Issue 2 and gather community feedback on Wednesday, Nov. 1 from 6-8 p.m. at Winton Hills Recreation Center.

Related


Issue 22 in a nutshell

This November, Cincinnati voters will decide whether or not to sell the CSR to Norfolk Southern in exchange for a $1.6 billion trust fund to shore up basic services for the city. The city estimates it would have an annual return on the investment ranging from $50 million to $75 million, up to three times what the city earns from owning the railroad now. Legally, earnings from the sale could only be spent on maintaining existing city facilities like roads, rec centers and fire stations, which city leaders say is crucial given the city’s $300 million deficit.

But the proposed sale of the CSR comes at a time of heightened public awareness of the sins of its buyer, Norfolk Southern. A train belonging to the rail behemoth derailed in East Palestine, a small Eastern Ohio village near the Pennsylvania border, on Feb. 3. The derailment ignited a chain of events that ended in a controlled burn of the train’s toxic load of chemicals. More than half of the small town is afraid to drink its own tap water to this day.

Cincinnati voters will decide on Issue 22 on Nov. 7.

Read the two motions below:

Follow CityBeat’s staff news writer Madeline Fening on Twitter and Instagram.

Subscribe to CityBeat newsletters.

Follow us: Apple News | Google News | NewsBreak | Reddit | Instagram | Facebook | Twitter | Or sign up for our RSS Feed

Related Stories