Mayor John Cranley

Mayor John Cranley

Mayor John Cranley handily won a second term tonight, besting opponent Councilwoman Yvette Simpson with 54 percent of the more than 60,000 votes cast.

All Cincinnati City Council members seeking re-election also got the nod from voters, though vacancies mean three new faces — Republican Jeff Pastor and Democrats Tamaya Dennard and Greg Landsman — will be taking seats come January.

Cranley’s win came from big turnout in precincts that also went to Cranley in the May mayoral primary. Other precincts Simpson won in that contest didn’t lean as hard toward her in the general, including some in places like Pleasant Ridge, College Hill and one representing Clifton that ended up a dead tie.

The mayor’s victory wasn’t assured — he lost the primary to Simpson by almost 11 points. But after that defeat, his campaign upped its ground game, fanning out across the city to knock on doors. The campaign also hired a new campaign manager, Chandra Yungbluth.

“This comeback city has made me the comeback kid,” Cranley said at his election party downtown at Americano Burger Bar. He claimed victory early, with 77 precincts and more than 10,000 votes still uncounted. Most of those votes were in west side districts that leaned heavily for Cranley in the 2013 election and the primary.

What fueled the victory after Cranley’s primary defeat? There seem to be multiple factors. In addition to a huge monetary advantage — he broke fundraising records on his way to a $2.3 million warchest, compared to Simpson’s $600,000 — Cranley’s campaign pressed hard on a few key issues that may have swayed more moderate voters. Beginning this summer, Cranley focused in on Simpson’s move in council asking Children’s Hospital to pitch in more money toward community development in Avondale as it sought city land, zoning changes and other items from the city for a $550 million expansion. Cranley and his supporters likened that ask to a “shakedown” of the hospital and ran negative mailers and TV ads about the issue. Simpson has said she was just trying to find a win-win between the hospital and community groups, who opposed the expansion as it was planned.

Cranley also played up his record — his role in helping to fix Cincinnati’s pension fund shortfall, his moves adding more police and fire personnel and his work attracting big developments to downtown and other neighborhoods.

Simpson did not concede right away after Cranley declared victory, and as the night wore on, the mood at her election event at Queen City Radio in Over-the-Rhine stayed festive. But when 176 of 188 precincts had reported their votes and Simpson still trailed by a few thousand, she threw in the towel, at least for this election.

She vowed to stay involved in the issues she campaigned on — fighting poverty, advocating for youth development, affordable housing and other progressive touchstones.

Online, supporters were already floating her as a potential candidate for other offices, including the 33nd District seat Democrat State Rep. Alicia Reece will be term limited out of next year.

“I actually keep my promises, and I plan to do it whether I’m in the mayor’s seat or not,” Simpson said.

Simpson says she will finish out her council term, which ends in January, by focusing on establishing an affordable housing trust fund, working on youth initiatives and on new proposals to fight heroin addiction.

Precincts in blue went to Simpson, while those in green went to Cranley. In tan precincts, the two candidates tied.

Cincinnati City Council incumbents Democrats P.G. Sittenfeld, David Mann, Chris Seelbach and Wendell Young, independent Christopher Smitherman and Republican Amy Murray were all re-elected. First-time candidate Pastor seems to have narrowly prevailed for the ninth spot on council, though Democrat Michelle Dillingham, just 200 votes behind him, wasn’t immediately conceding. First-time candidate Tamaya Dennard placed sixth in the vote tally, netting her a spot, and Democrat Greg Landsman prevailed in his second attempt to land on council with the seventh-most votes in the race.

Sittenfeld was again the top vote-getter on council, followed by Mann, Seelbach, Young, Smitherman, Dennard, Landsmann, Murray and Pastor.

Cincinnati Public School Board president Ericka Copeland-Dansby won another term. First-time candidates Ryan Messer grabbed the highest number of votes of the candidates, and first-timer Mike Moroski also got enough votes to grab one of four open spots on the seven-member board. Incumbent Melanie Bates took fourth place in the race — though there may be a recount if provisional ballots don’t widen the margin between her and fifth-place finisher Renee Hevia.

Voters soundly passed Issue 3, a levy renewal for drug addiction and mental health services, Issue 4, a renewal for health and hospitalization services, Issue 5, a slight levy increase for elderly care, and Issue 24, a Cincinnati Public Schools levy renewal. All passed with at least 65 percent of the vote.

Ohioans soundly approved Issue 1, which expands rights for victims of crime during court proceedings, with 77 percent of statewide voters saying yes. Issue 2, a measure attempting to lower prescription drug costs for state agencies, failed, with 76 percent of voters casting ballots against it after a long, contentious campaign in which foes and supporters of the amendment spent millions on TV ads, mailers and other campaign material.

Leave a comment