Jymi Bolden

Chris Rose (left) says the city has been shortsighted in implementing improvements on Mulberry Street; some neighbors disagree.

An Over-the-Rhine resident is stirring things up at Cincinnati City Hall over a street project he believes is a missed opportunity.

But other residents of Mulberry Street say he’s doing more harm than good.

Mulberry Street — the unofficial border between Over-the-Rhine and Mount Auburn — is getting a fresh layer of pavement and new sidewalks for the first time in many years. Last year the Water Works Department replaced a stretch of water main on the street.

Chris Rose, 32, a homeowner on the street for the past three years, appreciates that. But Rose thinks the $261,000 in street and sidewalk work is also a missed opportunity: What about brick sidewalks? What about decorative street lighting? Residents could have paid for both.

He believes the project was a chance to really improve Mulberry, which connects Sycamore and Vine streets. Now the street won’t get those kinds of improvements without starting up a whole new project and digging into the streets and sidewalks again.

Rose wrote a letter to city council and talked with Councilman David Pepper about his concerns. But Rose is not helping, according to members of the Mulberry Street Association, a group of more than a dozen residents that meets monthly to talk about trash pickup, abandoned buildings and other issues.

The city communicates to residents about its projects through organizations such as the association. Member Jeff Brandt says residents considered street lighting and other improvements, but dropped the issue after deciding the work would be too costly. Instead, members focused on getting speed bumps, which are on the way.

“(The city is) doing a fine job,” Brandt says.

The city installed two new streetlights in the past year, according to Brandt.

Rose says he had talked with officials from the Department of Transportation and Engineering last October and was told they would get in touch with him. The next city contact was a construction crew, he says.

“We heard a jackhammer in front of our door,” Rose says, standing outside his 137-year-old building at the peak of Mulberry Street.

Brandt says Rose has endangered the relationship residents developed with city officials during four meetings about the street rehab since 2001. Now city supervisors are yelling at their staff because of bad publicity, chilling their relationship with Mulberry residents, he says.

“The majority of people on Mulberry except one or two are really happy,” Brandt says.

Brandt says Rose’s actions are jeopardizing City Hall’s pledge of decorative trash cans — which a majority of the association wants.

A bargain anywhere else
Rose says the Mulberry Street project isn’t his main concern. He’s more worried about how the project — with or without decorative additions — ties into the future of the neighborhood.

“Who at the city is in charge of recognizing potential?” he says. “How are these new sidewalks being tied into the overall plan for Over-the-Rhine?”

Mulberry is a street mixed with vacant lots, vacant homes, rehabbers and low-income tenants of federally subsidized housing. About half of the 110 houses that were on the street in 1980 have been demolished, according to Joe Gorman, who’s building four homes on the street.

Some of the homes on Mulberry have delightful views of Over-the-Rhine and downtown. They are in a neighborhood between the city’s two largest employment centers, the University of Cincinnati and the central business district, Rose says.

Even so, property on the street is undervalued, he says.

“In any city, this view should cost a ton of money,” Rose says.

Rose figures his home — whose rear deck offers a wide view of Over-the-Rhine, including Music Hall and the Cincinnati Museum Center — should have cost three times the $135,000 he paid.

Rose says he wants Over-the-Rhine to become a place as unique and funky as New Orleans’ French Quarter. He’s just not sure City Hall is capable of getting the neighborhood there.

If the city is going to reverse its 40-year trend of losing residents — Cincinnati has only two-thirds of the population of 500,000 it had in 1950 — it will have to do most of it by filling in gaps on streets such as Mulberry, one vacant lot or house at a time.

There is demand for housing downtown, although it isn’t what it was a year or two ago, according to Arn Bortz, a partner in Towne Properties, one of the largest developers in the city’s center.

Towne Properties’ vacancy rates were 2 or 3 percent two years ago, but today stand at 15 percent.

Rick Greiwe, president of Downtown Cincinnati Inc., wishes there was demand for more housing units in the city’s center, especially in the form of large, luxurious condos for retiring baby boomers and young, single professionals.

“This is taking off like hotcakes in other (cities),” Greiwe says. “You just can’t find that product right now.”

Outside City Hall, the biggest blockade to redevelopment are stubborn property owners and real estate speculators, according to Bortz.

Unlike other cities, Cincinnati never had a complete bottoming-out of real estate prices, he says. Some of the people who own vacant lots and old buildings have no interest in putting them to productive use — unless they can get a very high price. They all seem to be waiting to hit the jackpot, Bortz says.

Greiwe says its more profitable for some owners to rent their land for parking than housing because the current downtown rents aren’t high enough. About 3,700 people live in the central business district; there’s room for 10,000, Greiwe says.

Over-the-Rhine offers similar opportunities. A near-final draft of the planning department’s comprehensive plan for Over-the-Rhine, due soon, will deal with big-picture ideas, such as how the city could pay for rehab work on the neighborhood’s dilapidated stock of housing. Putting the plan into practice will be a long, intensive, block-by-block effort.

The city is close to approving a new zoning code, which should make it easier to navigate projects through City Hall. New loan programs are offering thousands of dollars for developers to do market-rate housing.

But no one knows how much it will take to get the real estate market past the so-called “tipping point,” when developers no longer require city dollars to build new housing on streets such as Mulberry. ©

Leave a comment