Over the past six years, the state of Ohio paid now-defunct online charter school the Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow more than $14 million from funds that could have otherwise gone to Cincinnati Public Schools, Ohio Department of Education data compiled by charter school critics shows.
That money came from students in the CPS district — but much of it could have also gone to other online or brick-and-mortar charters had it not gone to ECOT. Still, critics say, that’s money that was spent on a school that ultimately failed to live up to its promises. CPS reported that 60 ECOT students enrolled in the district in the week after the charter closed in January.
Innovation Ohio, a left-leaning think tank that launched to oppose charter schools, compiled the data from the state.
“This is another piece of the growing ECOT scandal that has effected taxpayers in every corner of the state,” a statement from the think tank reads. “The numbers show that all but six of Ohio’s 613 school districts lost state funding to ECOT.”
ECOT closed earlier this year after the state of Ohio forced it to pay back millions in state funds related to a scandal over misreported attendance numbers. State officials say the school reported thousands of students were attending its online classes, but many seldom or never logged in to use the online school’s services.
In Ohio, charter schools are private nonprofit or for-profit schools funded with public money pulled from the public school districts where a charter schools’ students live. If a student in a district elects to go to a charter school over the public equivalent, the public school’s funding for that pupil is transferred to the charter. Generally, charters are held to lower educational standards that public schools. That’s because they are often taking lower-performing students from low-income backgrounds, supporters say. Critics, however, say that’s an unfair double standard.
Overall, more than $591 million went to ECOT from local districts, department of education data shows.
Prior to its closure, Ohio taxpayers had been paying $100 million a year to send 15,000 students to the school, which had no books, no classrooms and, according to state officials investigating its attendance records, little proof that it was providing educational opportunities required by the state.
But the school’s leadership said it was providing an invaluable service for students who can’t attend a brick-and-mortar school and that a 2003 contract between ECOT and the state stipulates that it cannot be held accountable for its actual attendance rates. School officials warned that if the state held it to those standards and stripped its funding, it would have to close.
That prediction came true this January, after the state announced it would require the school to pay back $80 million in taxpayer money from its final two years of operation.
School founder and Columbus businessman William Lager has been heavily involved in funding political campaigns, most of them Republican. In 2015, he gave $10,000 to the Ohio Republican Party, and in the past five years he has given more than $1 million to Republican lawmakers.
Critics, including state lawmakers, say the battle between the Ohio Department of Education and the privately run but publicly funded ECOT underscores problems with the state’s lax oversight of its charter system as a whole, especially embattled online schools.
A 2016 study commissioned by the Thomas B. Fordham Institute suggests that the state’s 24 online schools, like those run by White Hat and ECOT, weren’t providing their 35,000 students with a satisfactory education. While the institute generally supports charters, it found online schools in Ohio lacking.
“Online students are not achieving at the same level as their peers in brick-and-mortar schools,” the report said, noting that the online schools are dragging down the ratings of other charters.
Online charter advocates have shrugged off the report, saying that students who enroll in such schools often start out at a lower performance level.
This article appears in May 30 – Jun 6, 2018.


