Photo: Ryon Tunstull

A man and his 3-year-old son were browsing paper towels in Kroger when CityBeat approached. 

“Hello! I’m a reporter with Cincinnati CityBeat. Do you think I could talk to you about the recent ICE arrests in the neighborhood?” 

There’s a pause: “I have a translator here — she’s my intern, also a reporter.”

She introduced herself in Spanish, and his face relaxed slightly.

Under Kroger’s fluorescent spotlight, the man, who chose not to share his name, shared his immigration status with two total strangers. 

“Do you have citizenship status? Or a visa?” CityBeat asked.

“For now, no,” he said as his toddler peeked from behind his dad’s leg.

Originally from Guatemala, the man has lived in the Price Hill neighborhood with his family for 15 years. Naturally, he wants to keep it that way. 

“With everything that’s going on lately, are you worried about deportation?” we asked.

“At times we worry, but we put our hope in God that everything is fine,” he said.

Click here to read this article in Spanish.

Related


Promises made, promises rephrased

Since President Donald Trump reentered office in January, immigrant families like this have been living on hope and seeking legal advice to avoid arrest by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

Speaking at Madison Square Garden a week before the 2024 election, Trump made a promise to his supporters: his second administration would carry out “the largest deportation program of criminals in the history of America.” 

Press secretary Karoline Leavitt shared the administration’s definition of “criminals” in January.

“The 3,500 arrests that ICE has made so far since President Trump came back into office — can you just tell us the numbers?” One reporter asked. “How many have a criminal record versus those who are just in the country illegally?”

“All of them, because they illegally broke our nation’s laws, and therefore, they are criminals as far as this administration goes,” Leavitt replied. “I know the last administration didn’t see it that way. So it’s a big culture shift in our nation to view someone who breaks our immigration laws as a criminal, but that’s exactly what they are.”

Trump border czar Tom Homan maintains the administration has prioritized arresting “public safety threats and national security threats” since “day one.” 

But summer is here and the data is in: they’re not.

More than 75% of people booked into ICE custody in fiscal year 2025 had no criminal conviction other than an immigration or traffic-related offense, according to ICE records. The data covers the more than 185,000 immigrants who have been booked into ICE custody between Oct. 1, 2024 and May 31, 2025, which includes Biden’s final months in office. 

Those convicted of serious crimes like murder, assault, rape or robbery made up less than 10% of booked detainees.

DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin told CNN, which reviewed the data, that ICE targets “the worst of the worst — including gang members, murderers and rapists.” 

“In President Trump’s first 100 days, 75% of ICE arrests were criminal illegal aliens with convictions or pending charges,” she told the network. But McLaughlin did not respond to CNN’s request to clarify the nature of those convictions or pending charges.

Although the Trump administration has declared undocumented immigrants criminals because they entered the country without express permission, they are not held criminally or charged with a crime once in ICE custody — the matter is civil.

“There’s no other area of civil law where you get put into jail while your case is pending,” said Lynn Tramonte, director of the Ohio Immigrant Alliance. “Like, if I’m getting evicted from my home, they don’t put me in jail. If I don’t pay my taxes to my local government, they don’t throw me in jail, right? They give me a payment plan, and I work it out with them. That’s how immigration law should be.”

Research published in the American Economic Review analyzed two centuries of incarceration data and found that immigrants have had lower incarceration rates than U.S.-born people for 150 years. Those rates have only declined since 1960; immigrants today are 60% less likely to be incarcerated. The non-partisan American Immigration Council compared crime data to demographic data from 1980 to 2022 — the most recent data available — and concluded that crime rates actually declined in communities where immigrant populations grew.

Greater Cincinnati community members protest outside the Butler County Jail against recent ICE arrests on Sunday, June 8. Photo: Ryon Tunstull

Courthouse chaos

Despite most immigrants never committing crimes, many noncitizens are finding themselves handcuffed in courthouses thanks to a new ICE arrest tactic.

Sarah C. Larcade is an immigration attorney with the firm Larcade Law. She’s practiced immigration law for eight years, serving both Ohio and Kentucky clients. 

“I became an immigration attorney under the first Trump administration, so I was kind of thrown into the fire, which prepared me for this second administration,” she said. “This time, it’s like times 100.”

Trump’s deportation numbers, even in his first term, are nothing compared to former President Barack Obama, who removed 438,421 people in 2013 alone — a 21st-century record. 

“Obama deported more people than any U.S. president, but he also was trying to make sensible programs for people — except the most extreme people — that shouldn’t leave here, like children who came here when they were very young,” Larcade said. “There’s no balance under [the Trump] administration. It’s all scorched earth. We’re going after everyone. We’re taking you out of your home. We’re going to get rid of all the sensible measures that have been taken by previous administrations. They want numbers.”

A cell for two inmates at the Butler County Jail. This cell is one of 48 that make up a pod reserved for undocumented immigrants detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Photo: Aidan Mahoney

But Trump recently reached his own immigration crackdown milestone. On June 3, ICE set an arrest record of more than 2,200 arrests in a single day, according to the agency. 

Trump’s Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller has been pushing for an even higher daily quota.

“Under President Trump’s leadership, we are looking to set a goal of a minimum of 3,000 arrests for ICE every day, and President Trump is going to keep pushing to get that number up higher each and every single day,” Miller said.

To this end, senior ICE officials have urged officers to “turn the creative knob up to 11” by arresting “collaterals” — noncitizen immigrants encountered by agents while serving arrest warrants for others — according to internal agency emails viewed by The Guardian. 

One of the apparent strategies used to raise the numbers is deploying ICE agents to immigration hearings at courthouses across the country to issue final deportation orders. Larcade sees the tactic as a due process workaround.

“It’s actually really, really bad,” Larcade said. “If you are in the immigration court in front of the judge, they can’t give you an expedited removal order. That’s why [ICE] is now showing up, dismissing the case, and then, as soon as the noncitizen walks out with their case dismissed, [ICE is issuing them] expedited removal. It’s really sneaky, and it’s really gross.”

A leaked memo from the Department of Justice (DOJ), dated May 30 and obtained by NBC News in June, instructs immigration judges to dismiss cases to speed up expedited deportations by removing a 10-day waiting period designed to allow the immigrant’s lawyer to respond. 

Although immigration judges work for the DOJ, not DHS, both departments report to the same executive. Larcade believes the bottleneck muddies their ability to rule independently.

“It’s not a court that was created by the Constitution,” Larcade explains. “ICE is the party that files cases in immigration court, and they are housed under DHS. They are two separate agencies, but ultimately they’re all under the executive branch, and their boss, all of them, is the President.”

Historically, ICE would issue the expedited removal orders to noncitizens apprehended within 100 miles of the border after recently crossing. Not anymore. During his first days in office, Trump signed an executive order titled “Protecting the American People Against Invasion,” which expanded expedited removals nationwide to anyone who has been in the United States for less than two years, no matter their location.

Larcade said the expedited removal orders are final and do not guarantee due process, but she said having a lawyer by your side raises your chance of avoiding deportation. Just make sure that lawyer has a laptop handy.

“If it does happen, reserve your right to appeal, because as soon as you appeal, then you are still in the immigration court system, and they can’t give you an expedited removal order,” Larcade said. “But you have to reserve your right and get the appeal filed [immediately]. With ICE being [in the courthouse], unless you have an attorney with their laptop and before you exit the courtroom, you file your appeal, it’s kind of hard to preserve that.”

Related

Choose your fighter

With so many federal orders and laws stacked against noncitizens, it’s a dark time for both immigrants and their attorneys. Larcade’s phone started ringing off the hook immediately after the November election.

“There was a panic,” she said. “Like an increase in the volume of calls, even from current clients, saying, ‘What do we do with Trump being president?’ 

She said her new client numbers have nearly doubled, and many firms are at capacity, especially nonprofits that offer free or low-cost representation. With the demand for immigration attorneys high and firms overwhelmed, Larcade said it’s still important to be selective when choosing a lawyer. 

The tips she shared with CityBeat are not to be taken as legal advice, but she said identifying red flags and knowing what questions to ask could help you find the right attorney.

Notarios

Larcade said more noncitizens are seeking legal help from people without attorney licenses, who are more affordable but come with big risks.

“One of the things we see often, especially in the Hispanic community, there are people who are not attorneys, and they call themselves notarios, or notaries,” she said. “Because in immigration, there are some circumstances in which you don’t have to be an immigration attorney. You don’t have to be an attorney to help fill out paperwork and all that stuff. So we’ve been seeing non-attorneys that are advertising services, and of course, they charge a lot less.”

Beyond being a licensed attorney, Larcade recommends asking if they’re members of the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA).

“I don’t work for AILA and I don’t get paid by AILA at all — I am involved in my local chapter — but the resources and the alerts that you get, I personally believe it is impossible to keep up with the changes if you don’t have access to AILA’s resources,” she said.

Cost matters

“Beware. You do get what you pay for,” she said. “So if you are speaking to someone who is actually an attorney and the price is significantly lower than quotes you’ve received from other places, you do have to kind of remember that.”

Larcade clarified that she’s not referring to no-cost nonprofits. “They do amazing work,” she said. “It’s just that their caseload is so high that there’s a waitlist.” 

If you do find yourself speaking to an attorney with a very attractive price, ask why. Best-case scenario, they might receive grants to make their services so affordable. Worst case, you could be looking at a short relationship.

“The purely private firms — and I don’t even know that they do it on purpose — to reel people in, they might charge a very low down payment,” Larcade said. “I would ask, ‘Do you receive funding from any grants or anything like that?’ But I would also ask, ‘Are you going to represent me throughout the entire case?’ I’ve seen people paying a low payment to an attorney, and they’ll do one thing and then drop them.”

When choosing an attorney, Larcade said there are ways to keep costs down while still speaking with someone who is trained. Ask about payment plans or opt for a one-time consultation session. 

“A lot of firms charge for an initial consultation, but when you pay the consultation fee, the lawyer can give you concrete advice, even if you don’t end up hiring,” she said. “You can at least arm yourself with some knowledge.”

Get everything in writing

“If you are going to hire an attorney, the agreement needs to be in writing,” she said. “A good attorney is going to sit down and go through the contract with you in a language that you understand before you sign it.” 

Larcade also cautioned against signing a blank form. She said it’s like signing a contract before it’s been written.

“Don’t sign a form that you don’t know what is in it,” Larcade said. “Even if they tell you what they’re going to file and they just hand you the signature page and they say, ‘Sign this,’’ don’t sign something that you haven’t seen the form and it hasn’t been reviewed with you.”

Cincinnati’s missing son

Alongside courthouse arrests, ICE has begun arresting noncitizens who participate in the agency’s Alternatives to Detention (ATD) program, which consists of the Intensive Supervision Appearance Program (ISAP). The ATD-ISAP program, which began in 2004, allows noncitizens to live and work in their communities while on their path toward citizenship, as opposed to detention and deportation. This strategy saves the department money while providing case management for hopeful citizens, according to a description of the program on ICE’s website. 

Now, it’s a trap for deportation.

On June 4, protesters confronted ICE agents in Chicago after a dozen noncitizen immigrants were arrested during these scheduled check-ins. Family members of those arrested told reporters their loved ones were sent a text from ICE to report to their office, only to be arrested upon arrival. Similar cases have been seen in Alabama, California, New York and Ohio.

ICE defended the practice in a statement to NBC News.

“Those arrested had executable final orders of removal by an immigration judge and had not complied with that order,” an ICE spokesperson told the outlet. “If you are in the country illegally and a judge has ordered you to be removed, that is precisely what will happen. During the Biden administration, thousands of illegal aliens — including violent criminals — with final orders of removal were on ATD and allowed to roam our communities.”

The Cincinnati teenager targeted by this practice was not “roaming” the community. He was part of it. 

Emerson Colindres, a 19-year-old recent high school graduate, grew up on Cincinnati’s west side. His mom, Ada Bell Baquedano Amador, told CityBeat she and Colindres are very close.

Emerson Colindres Photo: Provided

“Anywhere I went, he wanted to go with me. We went to church together,” Baquedano said. “He’ll sit in my bedroom with me and we’ll talk for two, three hours.”

She’s lucky now to get a few minutes. ICE called the family on June 4 and ordered Emerson to report to the agency’s local office.

“We woke up in the morning around 9 a.m., they called us, they called Emerson, and they said that he needed to come in, that they were going to put an ankle monitor on him,” she said. “We got to the office, they took us back together, and two or three minutes later, they separated us and they took Emerson back alone.”

As a family with no criminal history, a pending U-visa application and perfect check-in attendance with ICE, Baquedano didn’t assume the worst for her son. Then she saw him in handcuffs.

“He said, ‘Mommy, they’re going to deport me.’ And I said, ‘Why? Our cases have always been together,” she said. “It really, really disturbed me.”

Baquedano brought her two young children to the United States in 2014 to escape violence in Honduras. Colindres was 8 years old. ICE agents at the border allowed them to enter the country, and Baquedano immediately started the process of setting up a case. 

The family got an attorney and applied for asylum. Between regular check-ins with immigration officials, they made a life for themselves in Cheviot, their new community. Baquedano brought her family to church, served food and cleaned houses with a work permit, and attended her son’s soccer games.

Colindres’ love of soccer was born in Honduras but blossomed in the U.S.

“He had really hoped to go to a college and play soccer,” Baquedano said. “The other young men on the team, Galaxy, they had been working with him to try to help him apply. There is a university in Kentucky they had all been looking at that seems to be open to immigrants, and he had hoped to one day turn professional.”

In 2019, the family’s asylum case was denied, so they appealed. An order of removal was issued for the family, but that doesn’t mean they were required to self-deport. 

CityBeat confirmed the legal nuance with an immigration attorney who declined to speak on the record. Under the law, it is up to the Attorney General to remove noncitizens who have an order of removal or subject them to supervision conditions. ICE approved the latter for Baquedano’s family. They were told to attend routine check-ins with immigration officials, and Baquedano, who has no criminal record, was given an ankle monitor.

“For the past 11 years, I have done every single thing that is asked of me,” Baquedano said. “I’ve been at every [immigration] appointment. I’ve answered every phone call. There has not been a single thing they’ve asked of me that I failed to do. Everything they asked, I say, ‘Yes, yes, yes, yes.’”

Their asylum appeal was denied in 2023, but they’ve had a separate application pending for U nonimmigrant status, also known as a U-visa. The program grants legal status for noncitizens and qualifying family members who have been victims of certain crimes while living in the United States, according to ICE. Applicants can still be granted a U-visa even if they have a removal order or check-in agreement with ICE.

When ICE arrested Colindres, Baquedano asked agents why only her son was being detained. Their immigration cases are together on one docket.

“They were just saying, ‘Well, just because.’ That was all they would say,” Baquedano said.

In the days after Colindres’ arrest, Baquedano searched for an attorney and legal options to free her son. Two days later, ICE delivered another blow.

“They told me [and my daughter that we] now have 30 days to leave the country,” she said. “I want you to imagine that you jump through every hoop that is put in front of you, and at the end, they still lie to you and they still say, ‘No.’”

Greater Cincinnati community members protest outside the Butler County Jail on Sunday, June 8 against recent ICE arrests. Photo: Ryon Tunstull

‘Free Emerson’

Word of Colindres’ arrest spread in Cincinnati. His soccer coach and teammates quickly organized a protest on June 8. They assembled outside the Butler County Jail, where Sheriff Richard Jones houses ICE detainees as a condition of a special contract with the federal government.

Roughly 200 people turned out for the protest. One protester ended up in handcuffs of her own. 

“Free Emerson! Free Emerson!” chanted the crowd, which included family, friends and former school teachers, many wearing shirts with the same phrase.

Bryan Williams, assistant coach of Colindres’ former soccer team, told CityBeat he’s coached Colindres since he arrived in the U.S.

“He’s the best player on the field every time we’re out there,” he said. “The last few years, he’s really found his voice and he’s coaching. We were trying to figure out a way to get him into college to play soccer. Now we’ve changed our focus to getting him out of jail.”

Colindres’ former high school history teacher, John Klinger, said the teen was also a stand-out student.

“He was a critical thinker,” he said. “He’s the type of person that you want around, the type of person you want to stay in a country, the type of person that makes society better.”

During the protest, Baquedano addressed the crowd through a microphone, her daughter Allison by her side.

“You have no idea what we suffer every night,” she said. “When the night comes, we know that he’s here. He’s somewhere that’s not safe. He’s never spent the night somewhere he’s not supposed to be.”

Despite legal motions to block Colindres’ deportation, he was transferred out of the Butler County Jail, driven to a Michigan airport, flown to a private ICE prison in Louisiana, and deported to Honduras on June 18.

Catholic Charities Southwestern Ohio, the organization providing legal representation for Colindres, described ICE’s treatment of Colindres as “extremely disturbing.”

Related

“This sort of clandestine and frightening treatment of a non-criminal 19-year-old is extremely disturbing, particularly because Emerson in no way matches the description of those whom the government has stated are priorities for deportation,” the statement reads. 

Tramonte, the director of the Ohio Immigrant Alliance, agreed there was no reason for Colindres’ deportation. Even with a removal order, he still had a right to see through the results of his pending U-visa application.

CityBeat asked Tramonte if she believed Colindres would have been deported under any other president — even deportation record-holder Obama.

“No, absolutely not, no way,” she said. “He has a path to a U-visa. All they had to do was wait and let him get the visa. One branch of the government is processing it and the other branch of the government sped up their process to deport him so that he couldn’t get it. It’s just patent cruelty.”

Related

Shifting policies

U-visas are adjudicated by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), Tramonte explained. Again, it’s all under the umbrella of DHS. 

Larcade said that the department used to consider U-visa cases, but not anymore. 

“They don’t care if you have a U-visa pending,” she said. “If you have an order of removal, they want to execute it.”

It’s another easy wand for DHS to wave to raise deportation numbers, but it’s also a system already backlogged with cases. Larcade said it can take up to 20 years to find out if your U-visa is approved, but allowing these applicants to remain in the country is actually a benefit to DHS and other law enforcement agencies.

“The U-visa is to keep someone here in the event that they are needed to testify or provide evidence or help in an investigation of a crime,” she said. “The administration is actually impeding the criminal justice system by removing people who are witnesses and victims and even defendants charged in state and local cases. You’re removing people, and that’s impeding the criminal justice process.”

Although DHS and all its core agencies are under the direction of the president, Congress has the power to create new laws that would change the way the department operates. Congress created DHS in 2002 through the Homeland Security Act, defining the department’s mission and structure.

But the 2024 election strengthened the power of immigration hard-liners on Capitol Hill. The Republican Party, which listed immigration among its top policy issues in its 2024 platform, secured control of the Senate and narrowed its majority in the House.

Rep. Greg Landsman (D-Ohio) represents Ohio’s 1st Congressional District, encompassing Cincinnati and the neighborhood where Colindres’ family lives. He told CityBeat that there’s a lot to be fixed in the immigration system, but deporting Colindres doesn’t advance the goal of “sensible” reform.

“Americans want a sensible, strategic and humane immigration system — this isn’t it,” he said. “Emerson came to Southwest Ohio as a young boy. He grew up here, went to school here and played soccer with his friends here. Tearing him away from his family won’t fix a broken system. It’s just cruel. His removal isn’t making any of us safer or better.”

Some Republicans have started to echo similar concerns and are speaking out against Trump’s crackdown on immigrant families with no criminal record.

Rep. David Valadao (R-California) said in a post on X that while he condemned the “violence and vandalism” seen in the L.A. protests against ICE arrests, the administration should “prioritize the removal of known criminals over the hardworking people who have lived peacefully in the [Central] Valley for years.”

Rep. Tony Gonzales (R-Texas) is chairman of the Congressional Hispanic Republican Conference. He told CNN that Trump needs to “focus on convicted, criminal illegal aliens.” 

“If we focus there and we’re not going after the milker of cows who’s in 103-degree weather — going after that guy, and we’re going after the convicted criminal, I think we’re on the right path,” he said.

Still, most House and Senate Republicans appear to be in line with Trump’s immigration crackdown. For some, it’s not harsh enough.

“Birthright citizenship — if neither of your parents are a U.S. citizen, you shouldn’t be a U.S. citizen,” Rep. Warren Davidson (R-Ohio) told CNN in June. 

Republicans in the Ohio Statehouse are similarly eager to harden immigration policy.

Ohio Senate Republicans approved Senate Bill 172 on June 18. The bill, now headed to the Ohio House, would prevent local officials from intervening against ICE officers arresting individuals without a warrant. 

State Sen. Kristina Roegner (R-Hudson) introduced the bill after judges in the Franklin County Common Pleas Court blocked ICE arrests within courtrooms unless ICE received approval from a local judge. 

Democrats have criticized the bill as “state-sponsored racial profiling.”

“It would turn Ohio into a police state, facilitating the masked abductions of more community members in all sorts of public places,” Tramonte said. “This bill would cause more Ohio children to lose the daily presence of mothers and fathers.”

CityBeat has confirmed that Colindres has arrived safely in Honduras. Thousands of miles separate the teen from his mother, his sister and the community that fought to keep him.

“It is the most difficult thing I have ever gone through,” Baquedano told CityBeat through tears. “I miss him so much.”

Editor’s note: After press time, CityBeat received confirmation that Banquedano and her daughter were leaving the U.S. on June 24 to be with Colindres in Honduras. Read more here.

Follow CityBeat’s staff news writer Madeline Fening on Instagram. Got a news tip? Email mfening@citybeat.com.

This story is featured in CityBeat’s June 25 print edition.