Replacement for Cincinnati City Council Member Amy Murray Poised to be Sworn in Tomorrow

Former assistant Hamilton County prosecutor and probate court magistrate Betsy Sundermann is set to get approval tomorrow after some wrangling behind the scenes

Mar 3, 2020 at 11:24 am
Hamilton County Probate Court Magistrate Elizabeth "Betsy" Sundermann - Hamilton County Courts
Hamilton County Courts
Hamilton County Probate Court Magistrate Elizabeth "Betsy" Sundermann

Cincinnati City Council looks likely to get a new member. 

Council member Amy Murray, who will resign March 4 to take a job in the administration of President Donald Trump, will be replaced by West Side Hamilton County Probate Court Magistrate Elizabeth "Betsy" Sundermann. 

Sundermann is expected to be sworn in at tomorrow's council meeting. Her term will end Dec. 31, 2021.

Her appointment comes after some wrangling. A committee of the Hamilton County GOP weeded through 16 applications and came to five finalists before overwhelmingly recommending Sundermann.

But Cincinnati's charter requires council members select another member or members to appoint their replacements should they vacate their seats early. Murray chose Vice Mayor Christopher Smitherman, an independent, and council member Jeff Pastor, a Republican, who at one point favored another candidate — attorney Steve Goodin. Murray clearly expressed her preference for Sundermann, however, and eventually got her way.

The selection committee recommending Sundermann was made up of Murray, her husband, GOP Finance Chair Nancy Aichholz, Josh Burton, Nan Cahall, GOP Vice Chair Kristie Davis, Charter Committee representative Bob Dehner, lobbyist Chip Gerhardt, former Hamilton County Commissioner Greg Hartman, Cincinnati USA Regional Chamber CEO Jill Meyer, Councilmember Pastor, GOP Chair Alex Triantafilou, former Murray chief of staff Alana Tucker and GOP Finance Director Maggie Wuellner.

Over the weekend, Goodin protested that the committee was "stacked" with Murray's supporters and that Sundermann's selection was preordained. He called the selection process "a sham." 11 members of the committee voted for Sundermann, two voted for Goodin and one voted for another candidate, Liz Keating.

Both Pastor and Smitherman, previously rumored to be Goodin supporters, have signed on to Sundermann's appointment, council documents show.

Sundermann was a GOP favorite due to her experience — she served 13 years as an assistant Hamilton County prosecutor — and because she hails from the city's West Side.

“For too many years, the city’s west side has not had a voice on City Council," Hamilton County GOP Chair Alex Triantafilou tweeted last week. "With @ElectAmyMurray recommending Betsy Sunderman (sic), Westsiders will have a person fighting for them once she’s appointed. This is great news for neighborhoods.”

Pastor today congratulated Sundermann on her appointment during council's Economic Growth and Zoning Committee, which Murray chairs. 

Murray was herself appointed to council to fill a seat vacated by Chris Monzel in 2011 when he won election to the Hamilton County Commission. She subsequently lost a bid for election that year, but won a seat in 2013 and again in 2017. She's ineligible to run again next year due to term limits. 

Murray is leaving to serve as the director of the Department of Defense's Small Business Programs. 

"It's so sad leaving the city, even though we always have chaos and drama... nothing is without that," Murray said today in committee, thanking Pastor and Smitherman. "But, we have been on every committee together through thick and thin and I just so appreciate all the work that you have done with us and moving the city forward, and economic growth and the stuff we've done with them on Law and Public Safety."

Cincinnati City Council will get another new member soon after the resignation of council member Tamaya Dennard yesterday. Dennard, who faces federal bribery and extortion charges, selected council member P.G. Sittenfeld to appoint her replacement. Sittenfeld said yesterday that he will announce the procedure to replace Dennard soon.