Trophy Pizza in Evendale channels the spirit of NYC walk-up pizza windows, delivering an unparalleled slice of the Big Apple in the Queen City. In addition to slices, pies come in two sizes: 20-inch round or rectangular “grandma” (a pan-baked, Sicilian-like pizza where the mozzarella goes on before the sauce). The standard cheese slice is large enough to be foldable, with a light, chewy crust topped with tangy red sauce, parmesan, mozzarella and just the right amount of grease, baked on a 600-degree pizza stone. There are margherita, white, pepperoni and a couple of specialty pies on the menu (like the Loophole, with chicken, cheese, bacon, jalapeño, caramelized onions and ranch), but choose-your-own toppings range from homemade meatballs and capicola to pineapple, arugula and artichoke. Helmed by veterans of the Brooklyn and Cincinnati bar/restaurant scene, they must be doing something right because they’re opening a second location in Norwood’s Factory 52 development, just one year after the grand opening of their original.
mytrophypizza.com.